Beja and beyond

Some interesting news this week from the Beja, an ethnic group of the Red Sea coast of Sudan and Egypt. It's unclear whether this rebellion is representative of the Beja's general feelings or just a figleaf for Eritrean intervention (or both), but it's a story to watch - and an excuse to bring up a cool language.

Beja is Afro-Asiatic* - either part of Cushitic or a separate branch, depending on who you ask - and happens to be among the most obviously similar languages to Semitic and to Berber. The noun morphology is already fairly suggestive:

	Beja definite article	Arabic noun endings	Kabyle obligatory prefix
Masculine nominative singular	u:-	-u	w-
Masculine accusative singular	o-	-a	a-
Feminine nominative singular	tu:-	-atu	t-
Feminine accusative singular	to-	-ata	ta-

And the pronominal object suffixes add credence:

	Beja	Arabic	Kabyle
me	-i, -o	-ni:	-iyi
you	-ok	-ka	-ik
us	-on	-na:	-aγ
you (pl.)	-okn	-kum	-kən

(Beja, apparently, has no third person suffixes.) However, what really clinches it is the verbal system. Beja has two principal classes of verbs: one that often takes prefixes, and one that usually just takes suffixes. In Semitic, the prefixes are used for the imperfect, and the suffixes developed from a stative (still to be seen in Akkadian) into a perfect; Berber mostly retains the prefixes, whereas only minor traces of the suffixes remain. The prefixes are especially telling:

	Beja	Arabic	Kabyle
I	a-	'a-	-γ
you (m.)	ti- -a	ta-	t- -ḍ
you (f.)	ti- -i	ta- -i:	t- -ḍ
he	i-	ya-	i-
she	ti-	ta-	t-
we	n-	na-	n-
you (pl.)	ti- -na	ta- -u:na	t- -m
they	i- -na	ya- -u:na	-n

while the suffixes are best exemplified in Beja in the conditional mood:

	Beja	Arabic	Dahalo general non-past (Cushitic)
I	-i	-tu	-o
you (m.)	-tia	-ta	-to
you (f.)	-tii	-ti	-to
he	-i	-a	-:i
she	-ti	-at	-to
we	-ni	-na:	-no
you (pl.)	-tina	-tum	-ten
they	-ina	-u:	-en, -ammi

Just for good measure, in the prefix verbs you also have a feature found in Akkadian (among other Semitic languages) and Berber but lost in Arabic: a present tense formed by doubling the middle radical (in Berber and Akkadian) or adding n before the middle radical (in Beja). Compare:

• Beja aktim ("I arrived") > akanti:m ("I arrive")
  
• Akkadian almad ("I learned") > alammad ("I am learning")*
  
• Tamasheq əlmədǎγ ("I learn", irrealis) > lammǎdǎγ ("I am learning", realis)
  

It's really remarkable, considering all this, that Afro-Asiatic research isn't more advanced. There are two etymological dictionaries out there, admittedly - Ehret's and Orel and Stolbova's - but, though valuable, they frequently disagree with each other, and neither has attained general acceptance.

* Some people think Afro-Asiatic is not proved. I can't think why. Omotic's membership is not entirely clear, but all the rest is just plain obvious.

* Previously misquoted forms corrected, thanks to Matthew Loran.